ClaimAudio · 15:08 — 16:38
Machiavelli was the first thinker in the European tradition to argue that a state could remain stable with more than one political party competing against each other, rather than requiring one party to annihilate the other.
Ada Palmer highlights an overlooked Machiavellian innovation: contrary to the prevailing assumption that factions must fight until one is exterminated, Machiavelli (citing Siena) argued competing parties could coexist and stabilize a state by venting tension through ongoing rivalry. ✦ AI generated
Ada Palmer · Dwarkesh Podcast · 2026-06-16 · original ↗
plays this moment only · 15:08 — 16:38
Machiavelli is the first person that we have ever in the European tradition to suggest that it could be viable for there to be more than one political party in a state at the same time, and that they would compete against each other and vent the society’s tension through competition and vie to try to dominate an election and then the next one.
verbatim transcript · starts at 15:08
Transcript · around this moment
15:08– Machiavelli’s analytical innovations
15:08– Machiavelli’s analytical innovations
Around this claim
Context · 3
The DSA is a separate party that should leave the Democratic coalition, as they are not interested in winning general elections or advancing progressive policy through governance.Rahm Emanuel · All-In Podcast · conf 70%The only way forward is to reject extremism and find common ground across party lines, because shutting down the government is wrong for the Commonwealth and the nation.John Fetterman · All-In Podcast · conf 65%Partisanship is the gravitational force that dictates every US election — 43 of 50 states can be predicted with 97% confidence today for 2028, and this polarization, not rigging, is why Democrats keep winning California.Nate Silver · All-In Podcast · conf 60%