ATRIUMsearch → argument graph
ClaimVideo · 46:32 — 53:04

Elizabeth wanted Mary killed privately but her officials refused to act without legal authority, so Burghley maneuvered behind Elizabeth's back to send the death warrant to Fotheringhay.

Despite signing the death warrant, Elizabeth hoped someone would privately kill Mary; when her jailer Paulet refused to murder without legal authority, Burghley gathered Privy Councilors and sent the warrant to Fotheringhay against Elizabeth's wishes. ✦ AI generated

Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · 2026-08-13 · original ↗

starts at this moment · 46:32

Elicited by

Why didn't she 2 years ago say to Lord Burghley can we not just get rid of her please now?

Does she want her kind of eliminated privately? And yes, that is absolutely what Elizabeth wants... She has Walsingham write a letter to Paulet... 'found out some way to shorten the life of that queen' in other words, Mary, 'do it.' And Paulet... replies to the Queen, 'God forbid that I should make so foul a shipwreck of my conscience, or leave so great a blot to my poor posterity to shed blood without law or warrant.'... Burghley now has the death warrant... he just thinks, 'Come on, let's crack on.' And so, he has a little sort of cabal, doesn't he? He gets some of the privy councilors to his house, and they agree, 'Yep, we're going to do this.' And they send the warrant to Fotheringhay.

verbatim transcript · starts at 46:32

Transcript · around this moment

46:41royals throughout medieval history have traditionally been eliminated. So, maybe you know, she could be drowned in a butt of Malmsey or suffocated with a pillow or, you know, a hot poker stuffed up her bum. I mean, whatever. All these kind of various methods that have been used to remove unwanted members of the royal family. But she needs someone to do it. And she is kind of expectant that

47:02someone will step up to the plate and answer her her needs. Because listeners may remember back in 1584, large numbers of her loyal subjects, so the Privy Council, members of Parliament, um particularly loyal members of the general public, had all signed something called a bond of association. And this bond had been deliberately targeted at Mary. And people who signed it had committed themselves, should Mary ever be found

47:30guilty of plotting against Elizabeth, to kill her. And essentially, it had formally committed them to a kind of lynch law. And this bond of association had been bundled into the parliamentary act. So, Elizabeth can say to people, well, this is now the law of the land. Why aren't people acting on it? And so, this is why she is prevaricating even once the guilty verdict against Mary has

47:53been brought in. She's essentially hoping that one of the signatories to that bond of association will do what they have pledged to do and quietly and silently kill Mary without Elizabeth having to sign her death warrant. >> What I don't understand is why though she I mean A why has it taken so long and why we've even got to this point and B you know this sort of oh I hope that

48:18somebody because of the bond of association will privately kill Mary, you know, all this. Why didn't she 2 years ago say to um Lord Burghley can we not just get rid of her please now? Like you know, you can you you must know poisoners, crack on and do it. Richard the 3rd style or getting rid of Edward the 2nd or getting rid of the Duke of Clarence or whoever. It's so

48:37easy to do. >> It's a great question and it's something that Mary Queen of Scots herself often pondered. So back in the days when she was able to communicate with the the French and Spanish ambassadors, she she wrote to them and said, "I think this is what's going to happen. I think I'm going to be poisoned. I'm going to be smothered by a pillow or whatever. This

48:52is what I suspect." But it doesn't take to think. You know, we've been casting the the Privy Council and the Protestant establishment in quite a dark light in this series. You know, they're practicing dirty tricks and um operating under the radar. But they do I think have quite a principled sense that the operations of the law should proceed. They are by definition very devout Christians and they don't want to just commit a murder

49:22below the radar. They think that justice should be seen to be done. Um and it's important for the reputation not just of the Privy Council, not just of English justice, but of their religion. That they are seen to be doing the right thing and I think that that ultimately is is the reason why. And so this is why even as Elizabeth is digging her heels in still and saying I'm not going to

Around this claim
Context · 8
The Throckmorton Plot's exposure hardened Burghley and Walsingham into committing to eliminate Mary, Queen of Scots, first tightening her confinement and then enacting the Bond of Association—a lynch-law provision making Mary liable to death for an assassination plot she may not even know of.Tom (Rest is History) · The Rest Is History · conf 90%Elizabeth refused to execute Mary because she did not want to set a precedent of killing an anointed queen, which would threaten the divine authority of monarchy itself.Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · conf 85%Walsingham orchestrated an elaborate sting operation using Gilbert Gifford and a beer barrel to intercept Mary's correspondence with Babington.Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · conf 85%Mary Queen of Scots explicitly approved the assassination of Elizabeth I in a letter intercepted by Walsingham's agents.Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · conf 80%Elizabeth signed Mary's death warrant under pressure from fabricated threats, but then attempted to have Mary quietly murdered without formal execution—though her jailer Paulet refused on moral and legal grounds.Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · conf 80%Elizabeth attempted to have Mary secretly murdered rather than publicly executed, but her jailer refused on grounds of conscience.Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · conf 70%Mary Queen of Scots gave written approval for the assassination of Queen Elizabeth, thereby committing treason and sealing her own fate.Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · conf 70%The Bond of Association created a legal mechanism to execute Mary Queen of Scots for any assassination of Elizabeth, regardless of her knowledge.Tom Holland · The Rest Is History · conf 65%