AI-generated video podcast content fails because AI writes bad scripts that people instantly recognize as slop, destroying credibility — the value of this content is the human take, not an AI summary.
Wes critiques Hey Gen's new AI video podcast feature: technically impressive but likely unwanted for most, with its best uses being summarization and training content; the core problem is that AI-written scripts are instantly recognizable, and people listen for the human's interpretation, not a canned AI digest. ✦ AI generated
Wes (Host) · Syntax · 2026-08-04 · original ↗
starts at this moment · 42:05
it's technically extremely impressive that this looks really good... But on the same side, I don't know that people necessarily want this type of thing where it is just entirely AI generated... AI sucks at actually like writing a good script for this type of thing... I can within like 5 seconds I can hear when somebody has used ChatGPT or AI to write a script... people don't want to hear your garbage AI script... We listen to this type of stuff for the person, for their take on it, for their reaction to it, not for some garbage summarized version of it.
verbatim transcript · starts at 42:05
42:00on the list here. And Wes has something that I found to be pretty disturbing, honestly. This Hey Jen video podcast, which I think sucks. Uh Wes, what do you think? >> Well, okay. I was I changed my mind after Scott baffled the [snorts] uh all the things. He can't baffled. Not even saying the right thing. Anyways, Hey Jen, which is a uh a company that will train video on
42:25your likeness. So, you'll be able to I've used it. I used it like a couple years ago and I've recently tried it as well. Basically, you can like upload a video and audio of you talking and it will be able to create um video of that. And we saw a similar thing with Sora. there's a bunch of people sort of in the space. Um, and they released a new
42:44feature which is video podcast which is essentially just like two people sitting in a room talking back and forth. Um, and it's so odd because a technically extremely impressive that this is like this looks really good. Um, if you look really closely, you can you can tell and there's there's things that are like odd about it. But it is very very impressive that you can actually do this, right?
43:09But on the same side, like I don't know that that people necessarily want this type of thing where it is just entirely AI generated. Where I think this will do well is um AI is really good of if you can give it a whole bunch of data sources and say just please summarize and distill this down into a document that I can read. But also a lot of
43:31people do this as well for like I just want turn this into a 20-minute podcast that will teach me something. I think that's that's a great use case. >> [snorts] >> The other use case that this is great for is um like training, you know, like you got to sit you got to sit through safety training at your work or whatever. God, you know, >> this is good. People are going to use
43:52this like crazy. But other than that, I don't think people actually want this. And I think the most important thing is that AI sucks at actually like writing a good script for this type of thing. I can hear I scroll through Tik Tok, Instagram, reals all the time and I can within like like 5 seconds I can hear when somebody has used CHP or AI to write a script. And if you're trying to
44:17get into the space, you're trying to build something, people don't want to hear your garbage AI script that's over and over. People can notice it right away. You're going to immediately lose all of your credibility. We saw that this weekend with Hank Green, who's like a massive I guess like science YouTuber, sock salesman. He DM'd me when I was doing my sock thing. He people noticed that he was he was has
44:43all these like little chat GPT isms. And then he came out and says, "I have an unhealthy relationship with AI." Um, which is really funny because everybody thinks that they know where the bar is for their healthy relationship with AI. And I don't think it's a huge deal that he used it to help him and to to assist with writing his his script, but he just straight up was reading the script that
- ·HeyGen's AI video podcast feature: technically impressive
- ·Likely unwanted for most real creators
- ·AI-written scripts are instantly recognizable as slop
- ·Destroys credibility
- ·Best uses: summarization and training content
- ·Wes can hear AI scripts within 5 seconds
- ·People don't want garbage AI scripts
- ·Value is the person's take and reaction
- ·Not a canned summarized version