Video · 2026-07-16 · 11m · 6 moments

AI Is Stealing From You

✦ AI generated

timeline · colored by role

Claim◆

Using AI for instant answers instead of struggling with problems yourself robs you of the opportunities to learn, think critically, synthesize information, sit with discomfort, and develop determination and problem-solving skills.

The speaker argues AI is 'stealing' from users by removing the struggle and friction that normally builds learning, critical thinking, and problem-solving abilities.

transcript

Host: AI is stealing your opportunities to learn, it's stealing your opportunities to think and synthesize information as well as form your own opinions, it's stealing your opportunities to develop determination and sit in discomfort while learning and working.

explains mechanism · 1extends · 1supports · 3

Data◆

In a study, students who used unguarded AI for math practice scored higher initially but scored 17% worse than students who used no AI at all once the AI was removed for the exam, showing the learning gains were illusory.

A 2025 University of Pennsylvania study found students using unrestricted GPT-4 scored 48% higher during practice but 17% worse than a no-AI group once AI access was removed for the exam.

transcript

Host: The students using AI with no guardrails scored 17% worse than the group that had no AI at all. The moment the AI was taken away, the advantage went with it.

Claim

If you let AI do your critical thinking and opinion-forming for you, you are effectively tying your ability to think and work to a subscription owned by a for-profit corporation that controls the model's training and interpretation of information.

The speaker warns that outsourcing thinking and opinion-forming to AI makes people permanently dependent on a corporate-owned subscription and its embedded biases.

transcript

Host: You're essentially saying that your ability to critically think and do your work, or do your school work, or do your job is now directly tied to an AI subscription owned by a corporation.

rebuts · 1

Example

Just as good parents let bored kids sit with that boredom so they develop curiosity and creativity, people need to sit with the discomfort of not knowing something rather than immediately resolving it with AI.

Using the analogy of parents letting kids sit in boredom, the speaker argues that tolerating discomfort and uncertainty is what builds patience, curiosity, and critical thinking.

transcript

Host: Kids are running around saying, 'I'm bored. I'm bored.' But good parents will let their kids sit in that boredom and figure out what to do with it. They explore the curiosities. They get interested in building things with Legos or learning about electronics or doing art or making up stories.

supports · 1

Data

In a study on productive failure, students who struggled to solve math problems on their own before receiving instruction developed significantly greater conceptual understanding and ability to transfer knowledge to new problems than students taught the concept first.

Manu Kapur's 2014 'productive failure' study found students who failed at problems before instruction gained deeper conceptual understanding than those taught directly first, even though procedural knowledge was equal.

transcript

Host: The students who struggled and failed first developed significantly greater conceptual understanding and ability to transfer to novel problems. And the number of different solution attempts students generated during the failure phase predicted their learning outcomes.

explains mechanism · 1gives example · 1

Data◆

A McGill University study found that heavier lifetime reliance on GPS caused worse spatial memory over time, showing that outsourcing a cognitive skill to technology degrades that skill, which suggests AI usage could similarly degrade thinking, debugging, writing, and reasoning abilities.

Citing McGill research showing GPS reliance degrades spatial memory over time, the speaker argues daily AI use likely degrades our ability to think, debug, write, and reason.

transcript

Host: The more someone relied on GPS over their lifetime, the worse their spatial memory got. And a 3-year follow-up study showed the decline was steeper for heavier users. So, they didn't start out as bad navigators. GPS made them bad navigators. The brain stopped building mental maps because the phone was building them instead.

supports · 1

Highlight slides

AI Is Stealing Your Struggle✦ from: Using AI for instant answers instead of struggling with problems yourself robs you of the opportunities to learn, think critically, synthesize information, sit with discomfort, and develop determination and problem-solving skills.What Gets Lost✦ from: Using AI for instant answers instead of struggling with problems yourself robs you of the opportunities to learn, think critically, synthesize information, sit with discomfort, and develop determination and problem-solving skills.AI Practice Gains Were Illusory✦ from: In a study, students who used unguarded AI for math practice scored higher initially but scored 17% worse than students who used no AI at all once the AI was removed for the exam, showing the learning gains were illusory.Practice Boost vs. Exam Reality✦ from: In a study, students who used unguarded AI for math practice scored higher initially but scored 17% worse than students who used no AI at all once the AI was removed for the exam, showing the learning gains were illusory.GPS Reliance Weakened Spatial Memory✦ from: A McGill University study found that heavier lifetime reliance on GPS caused worse spatial memory over time, showing that outsourcing a cognitive skill to technology degrades that skill, which suggests AI usage could similarly degrade thinking, debugging, writing, and reasoning abilities.The Warning for AI Use✦ from: A McGill University study found that heavier lifetime reliance on GPS caused worse spatial memory over time, showing that outsourcing a cognitive skill to technology degrades that skill, which suggests AI usage could similarly degrade thinking, debugging, writing, and reasoning abilities.

Related episodes

Video · a16z Podcast

Ben Horowitz on the Global Race for Tech, Power, and Influence

→

Video · Lenny's Podcast

The rise of taste, human authenticity and judgment in an AI world | Adam Mosseri (Head of IG)

→

Audio · All-In Podcast

SpaceX-Cursor Deal, SaaS Debt Bomb, New Apple CEO, SPLC Indictment, Colon Cancer Spike

→